Forum Closed

The forum is now to new posts. All the historical content is still available to browse.

if you are looking for musicians to play with, please view the Bands Seeking Musicians list, or use the Musicians Directory

You can use our pages on social media to connect:

Melvins - (A) Senile Animal
Message Board > Album Reviews > Melvins - (A) Senile Animal
[Jump to Last Post] 
Mr. Hell
User Info...
Holy fuck!
Can't stop listening to this. The dual drumming translates well onto CD. The bass sound is just phenomenal and huge. Buzzo is top notch on both fronts.
One of their best if not the best. Lots of drum interludes and no noise BS.
My faves include:
Civilized Worm
A History Of Drunks
Rat Faced
The Hawk
A History Of Bad Men
Just get it and post your opinions. - Tue, 19 Sep 2006 4:13pm Edited: Tue, 19 Sep 2006 4:31pm
BM
User Info...
Yes, this album is most excellent. The dual drummers sound huge. I found the production to be lacking a bit, but the drums more than make up for it. Dale Crover is the flam king! - Thu, 28 Sep 2006 10:50pm
trevor corey
User Info...
Trevor confused.
I went to the record store to pick up this new Melvins album only to be told it isn't out yet. WTF?
I really enjoyed their project with Jello Biafra. - Thu, 5 Oct 2006 7:13pm
Mr. Hell
User Info...
Fuck, Trevor. I fuckin' downloaded it. Now go buy me some pepperoni and jalapino chips. - Sat, 7 Oct 2006 10:15am
trevor corey
User Info...
Thanks Mr Hell.
You're swell! - Sat, 7 Oct 2006 12:52pm
moron
User Info...
"One of their best if not the best."

Um, what? Maybe if the only album you had ever heard before that was "Stoner Witch".

The album is mediocre at best, personally I think it sucks. It has maybe 30% passable (not brilliant mind you) old school Melvins sounding stuff then a wack of crap that sounds like Pantera meets Audioslave. I've said it elsewhere but what the album really sounds like is a band making fun of the Melvins.

Doesn't compare favourably to "Houdini" even since that album at least had some true school Melvins brilliance to it. The production is wack too, all mid-range and 80s reverb sounding, very little oomph which is so important to the Melvins sound.

Stick with the first 3 albums and EggNog as everything since then is mostly an exercise in frustration.

IMHO

Cheers - Sat, 18 Nov 2006 2:45pm
Mr. Hell
User Info...
The lovely art of opinions.
I always preferred the actual songs by The Melvins, not so much the wacky, noisy off-the-wall stuff...although some of that is good for my ears.
This album is consistent and heavy, which are two important things I look for in a recording. Not to mention the endless supply of catchy, groovy riffs and Crover drumming. Sure, nothing on here touches The Bit, but it all translated well live and on a big, loud stereo it's a great listen.
The production is somewhat mid-rangy, but the bass sound is monstrous so it works for me. It sounds way cleaner and heavier than the older stuff. Of course this comes with technology and budget increases as well as experience.
Gotta love the purists, though! Keepin' it pure and keepin' it real! - Sun, 19 Nov 2006 1:57pm
Not logged in Log In / Register (optional)

Featured Events

Featured Historical Events

Featured Article

Melanie Golder
from Victoria BC
The 11th HOUR
Classic Rock, R & B, Country from Duncan BC
The Maroons
from Victoria BC
no organizations/resources found

Search the Directory / Archive

List an Event in the Calendar

List a Physical Single Date or Recurring Event

For physical events that happen at a specific time. For example a concert, or dance performance. If there are multiple shows, you can still duplicate your event to cover them all.

List an Online Livestream Event

For online / livestream events. This will allow you to include a livestream url and have it featured in our livestream listings.

Submit a Profile to the Directory

List a Music Band / Ensemble

(Band / Choir / Orchestra etc.)

List an Individual Musician

(Guitarist, Singer, DJ etc)

List a Music Resource

Venues, Event Promoters, Support Services etc.

News + Media

Log In to Your Account